[credit: Neang Thy/FFIU] |
More: A new paper (Zimmerman & Kormos) concludes that sustainable logging of rainforests is not economically viable or even practical given the complexities of tropical rainforest ecology. Just three rounds of logging resulted in the near extinction of desired wood species in all zones of tropical forest. When loggers plunder target trees and leave the surrounding forest undisturbed, the ecological balance responsible for nurturing those trees is disturbed. Most desired species are long lived and slow growing. They are sparsely scattered and rely on animal diversity for spreading their seed indicating large areas of undisturbed forest are vital to their survival. When these high value trees are removed, the remaining forest declines in economic value until lower level colonizers like monoculture plantations and ranches move in resulting in the clear cutting of the forest. It is an economic model similar to the one depleting the worlds ocean of fish. Low-impact logging advocated by some scientists as a "middle way" and subsidized by the UN REDD+ program is not an answer according to the study authors. Low-impact logging leaves 20-50% of the forest canopy open which has significant impacts on forest moisture. The species that replace the logged trees are frequently of low to no commercial value. Logging interests know this succession already; they engage in "cut and run" operations since they involve less expense and more short term gain. Truly sustainable forest cutting would require an interval of sixty years or more between cuts and be restricted to less than five trees per hectare. Such restriction are simply not economically sustainable on a commercial level. The study authors think selective logging by local communities is preferable to clear cutting for oil palm plantations or cattle pastures, but given that, industrial should not be subsidized since it leads in their opinion to eventual forest clearance. They suggest a temporary moratorium on cutting in primary rainforests might be helpful until a new economic model based on community logging with a long term stake in the health of the forests locals live near can be worked out and funded.