Judge Brian Morris of the Federal District Court of Montana ruled that the federal government failed to account for the pipeline's contribution to the world's climate disaster, saying it "simply discarded" the significant effects. The EPA estimated in February that construction of the pipeline would contribute an extra one billion tons of greenhouse gas emissions. Hair Further lamely labeled the decision "politcal" and a "disgrace". Judge Morris is an Obama appointee. Citing Supreme Court precedent, the judge wrote, “An agency cannot simply disregard contrary or inconvenient factual
determinations that it made in the past, any more than it can ignore
inconvenient facts when it writes on a blank slate.”
The 1179 mile large diameter pipe would carry 800,00 per day south to refiners in the Gulf Coast region. Exploiters have typically emphasized the minuscule economic benefit in the form of jobs, while turning a blind eye to the environmental damage the additional burning of fossil fuel will cause. The legal problem for the regime is a detailed, fact-based explanation, in light of contrary findings by the previous administration, for reversal of the previous policy denying State Department permission for the international pipe's construction. Two days after he took office, Mr. Yuge issued a fiat reversing Obama's decsion against the project, elevating the project to a political cause celebre, a symbol of 'Making America Great Again (MAGA). What his decision making on the project does is isolate the United States from the international community of nations who have signed the Paris Climate Accords, and indeed reject mainstream scientific thinking on climate change. The Trump regime has sought the reversal of 76 rules related to protecting the environment.
Experts think that the impact of the pipeline on the nation's economy is out of proportion to the political upheaval created over its permiting. The pipeline will primarily benefit Canada's oil shale operators by giving them an outlet to coastal refineries for their land-product. Their product is low-grade crude which requires huge amounts of water and fuel to process. The State Department estimated that 42,000 temporary jobs for two years — about 3,900 of them in
construction and the rest through indirect support, like food service —
but only 35 permanent jobs would be created.